Posted on November 29, 2022
Posted by John Scalzi
Initially: The higher than little bit of whimsy, produced by Midjourney from the prompt “A peppermint kaiju in a gingerbread town.”
Second, some views about AI-produced art I’ve had not too long ago, which I posted on my personalized Fb account but am reposting below to open up the dialogue a little bit. I wrote:
I have enjoyable participating in with AI-created art, and also, as another person who has a lot of artist close friends, I have qualms and worries about how their pre-current art is used for “training” in a way that is both equally qualitatively and quantitively diverse from human mastering, and how that use impacts artist livelihoods. More particularly with regard to the latter, the query is how does what I do with AI art have an influence on actual stay artists.
It’s effortless to say right here “there are no easy answers” but for me there are in actuality a couple of easy-ish answers in how I may well solution and use AI-created artwork in my personal and skilled life. They are:
1. I experience it’s all correct to use AI-produced artwork for personal enjoyment and visual inspiration, or to use it in a location in which I could use my possess art/pictures or Imaginative Commons-licensed artwork/pictures, and the place there is no intent to make money from the artwork, or from what it accompanies (like social media or site posts).
2. In all other circumstances, and particularly when there’s a professional intent or software, or when I would otherwise seek the services of an artist, I will seek out out artists and commission artwork from them. Also, explain to artwork administrators/other individuals that my function for them desires to be illustrated/marketed by artwork from artists, not AI era (I do not assume I will have to convey to them this, not the the very least because of copyright challenges encompass AI-produced art, but still).
As a tiny example: Despite the fact that I have been possessing a ball generating holiday-similar pics with AI, when it will come to vacation cards, I’ll be commissioning art (or making use of my possess photos) for the reason that that’s a time when I would retain the services of an artist or use my personal photos. As a larger illustration, it’s possible in the nearish long run I’ll need to collaborate with artists for tasks, and there’s no issue, for lawful, simple and ethical factors, that AI-produced art is not the way to go for that.
The limited model is: Use artists, and make an intentional, affirmative decision to use artists (also, shell out artists relatively for their do the job, not just because I can manage it but mainly because also that should just be the baseline assumption).
I believe AI artwork era is enjoyment. I also assume it calls for recognition on my component that these photos do not occur from nowhere. Quicker or later, they appear from artists. I really do not want my entertaining to hurt the artists I know, or the types I really do not.